Family owned and operated, all products are made in house, daily.  Our dough is made daily; we use the finest Mozzarella cheese on the market; our pizza sauce is made in house, using fresh herbs, garlic and whole peeled tomatos.  

All food is prepared while you watch, no hiding in the kitchen ~ you get an authentic New York pizzeria experience!

We are proud to serve delicious New York style HAND TOSSED, thin crust pizza.

Pizza Pete comes straight off the boat from a small town in Sicily, Melissa comes from the fabulous borough of Brooklyn, NY.

After spending 25+ years in York, PA, they relocated to this incredible Island.  Rather than retiring, opened up this little pizza joint to offer a quality slice in paradise.  


Quality Ingredients

Family Business

239 283 7992